Frankenstein has been reduced to a silhouette: a flat-headed giant with electrodes in his neck, groaning on a slab while lightning cracks over a tower. That silhouette belongs to Universal's 1931 film and to a century of fancy dress. It does not belong to the novel. Nor does the name: in the book it is the maker's, not the made thing's. The costume took the scientist's surname and left his crime behind.
In Shelley's novel there is no laboratory spectacle, no hunchbacked assistant and no lightning bolt. The method is withheld in a sentence, deliberately. And the creature talks. He talks for a third of the book, in long, formal, well-read sentences, and what he does with that third is prosecute the man who made him. The horror is not that a man built a living thing. It is that he built one, looked at it, and left the room.
The setup. A ship's captain, Robert Walton, is trapped in Arctic ice and writing home to his sister. He takes aboard a dying man, Victor Frankenstein, who explains how he came to be out there: a comfortable Genevan childhood, an obsessive stretch at the university of Ingolstadt, a body assembled and animated, and abandoned within minutes of opening its eyes. The creature survives, educates itself, and comes back with a single demand: a companion made like him. The refusal sets everything else in motion. Three narrators, nested — Walton around Victor, Victor around the creature.
The creature is given the floor
The centre of the novel belongs to the creature, and Shelley does not undercut him. He gets first-person narration and uses it well. He puts his hand in a fire because he cannot yet tell heat from light. He watches a poor exiled family through a chink in the wall of their outhouse and teaches himself speech by listening to them. He finds three books in an abandoned bag — Paradise Lost, Plutarch's Lives, Goethe's Werter — and takes from them, in order, rebellion, politics and self-pity.
Then he makes his argument: that he was benevolent to begin with, that misery made him what he is, and that happiness would make him good again. Victor has no reply. He haggles over terms and never once disputes the principle, because the principle is indefensible. That is the effect of the structure: the reader hears the prosecution before the sentence is passed. By the time the creature kills, we have been inside his reasoning, and we know more than the man narrating.
Walton's frame is doing similar work. He is risking a crew to reach the pole and be famous for it — Victor twenty years earlier, caught in time. The only sound judgement anyone shows in the book is Walton turning his ship around.
The crime is abandonment, not creation
The animation scene is the most quoted passage and it takes barely a paragraph. What follows takes the novel. The creature opens its eyes, Victor looks at it, and Victor walks out and goes to bed. He sleeps. He wakes to find the thing standing over him and runs from the building. He does not look for it, feed it, name it or tell a soul. He falls ill, is nursed for months by his friend Clerval, and recovers into relief that it seems to have gone.
Read that way, this is not a novel about the limits of science. Victor's science works. The experiment is a success. What fails is a man's nerve. Shelley gives the creature an infancy — cold, hungry, frightened of his own reflection, with nobody to explain anything to him — and his first lesson is that everyone who sees him recoils, his second that this will never change. Every killing afterwards follows the logic of an abandoned child: if you will not love me, I will take everything you love. The subtitle points at Prometheus and the theft of fire. The book is far more interested in the morning after.
Money, standing, and who can afford to speak
The Frankensteins are rich, and the plot runs on it. Genevan money pays for Ingolstadt, for two unexplained years, for a walking tour, for a hut in the Orkneys where Victor begins the female creature and then tears her apart while the creature watches at the window, and finally for a pursuit across Europe and into the Arctic. Nobody ever asks him to account for himself.
The creature owns nothing: no name, no papers, no money, no claim on anyone. He cannot take a room or buy a hearing. The one person who treats him kindly is a blind man, and it lasts exactly as long as it takes the family to come home and see him.
Then there is Justine. The household's servant, raised by the family and loved by it, is tried for the murder of Victor's small brother on the evidence of a miniature planted in her pocket. Victor knows she is innocent. He says nothing, because speaking would mean explaining what he has made. He goes to the trial, writes at length about his own torment, and lets her hang; she confesses to the killing because her confessor presses her into it. She has no money, no standing and no advocate. He has all three and withholds them. This is the coldest thing in the book, and it is easy to skim, because Victor's narration is so busy with Victor. The novel's verdict on him is here, not out on the ice.
Elizabeth belongs to the same pattern. In the 1831 text she is an orphan taken into the house, with no means of her own, promised to Victor in childhood by his mother. She waits years for a man who will not tell her what is wrong and will not call it off, and she is killed on their wedding night because Victor assumes that a threat made to him is a threat against him.
Which Frankenstein you are reading
Two texts are in circulation. The 1818, published anonymously in three volumes, written by a woman of twenty. The 1831, revised at length by a thirty-three-year-old Shelley for a cheap single volume, which is the version most editions still print.
The differences are not cosmetic. The 1831 Victor is more fated and less culpable; destiny and doom thicken in the prose; the religious framing is firmer; Elizabeth is changed from Victor's cousin to an adopted orphan, which sharpens her dependence and tidies the marriage plot. The 1831 also carries the famous introduction about the ghost-story competition at the Villa Diodati, which has since done more for the book's fame than most of its chapters. Most reprints do not say on the cover which text they carry. The quickest tell is that introduction: if it is in the book, you are reading the later version.
If you want the harder novel, read the 1818, where Victor's ruin is entirely his own work. If you read the 1831, keep in mind that it was rewritten by a woman who had buried three children and her husband, under pressure to be less radical than she had been at twenty. Either way, check which one you are holding. They leave different impressions of whether any of it could have gone otherwise.
What does not work
A fair amount. Victor faints, takes to his bed and succumbs to brain fevers so often that the illnesses stop registering as events; they are a mechanism for clearing him off the stage while the plot gets on with it. The coincidences creak badly. The creature happens to find Victor's laboratory journal in the pocket of the coat he stole, which is how he learns whose fault he is. He happens upon the one cottage in Europe containing an articulate exiled family who read aloud to each other. Everyone Victor loves dies in a convenient order, spaced to allow a chapter of lamentation after each.
Elizabeth is not a character. She is a promise, then an anxiety, then a corpse, and her letters sound like everyone else's. Clerval is a function. The long back-story of Felix, Safie and the Turkish merchant exists to teach the creature to read and teaches the reader to skip.
The morals are over-explained. Victor announces the lesson of his own life repeatedly, in the same elevated register, with the same gestures at heaven and the elements, and Shelley lets him do it. The scenery arrives on cue — Mont Blanc, the Mer de Glace, the storm on the lake — each with its allotted paragraph of sublime feeling. A reader can lose patience with a narrator who has this much to apologise for and this much vocabulary for apologising.
None of it sinks the book, because the creature is still in it and still talking. But this is not a well-made novel. It is a novel with one enormous idea in it, written by someone who had not yet worked out which of her scenes were earning their place.
A creature that argues back
Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, by Mary Shelley
Victor Frankenstein assembles a living man and walks out of the room within minutes of opening his eyes. What follows is not a monster story but a sustained argument about abandonment, responsibility and who gets listened to, with the creature himself making the case. A founding text of both Gothic fiction and science fiction, and still the most readable of either.
Discover Frankenstein by Mary Shelley on Amazon
About the author
Mary Shelley (1797-1851) was born Mary Wollstonecraft Godwin in London, the daughter of the philosopher William Godwin and the writer Mary Wollstonecraft, who died days after the birth. She began Frankenstein at eighteen, during the cold wet summer of 1816 at the Villa Diodati on Lake Geneva, where Byron suggested the party each write a ghost story. She had already buried her first child, born prematurely the year before.
The novel was published in 1818 with no author's name on it; the preface was by Percy Bysshe Shelley and the dedication was to Godwin, so many readers assumed Percy had written it. She had married him in 1816; he drowned off the Italian coast in 1822, leaving her a widow at twenty-four with one surviving child out of four. His father withheld the family money until his own death in 1844, so for two decades she supported herself and her son by writing, and by editing and promoting her husband's work.
Her other novels include Valperga (1823), The Last Man (1826), which ends with a single human being alive, Lodore (1835) and Falkner (1837). Mathilda, written in 1819, was not published until 1959. She died in London in 1851, at fifty-three, of a brain tumour.
To carry on with the series: The Metamorphosis: the insect nobody has ever seen, another body that empties out a family home; and The Tunnel: the confession of a man who reasons everything through, another narrator who reasons his way to a killing.
This article carries affiliate links. If you buy the book through one of them, we earn a commission. It has no bearing on which books the series covers, or on what is said about them.